Reality test: COVID-19 is deadlier than the 1918 Spanish flu


Roughly 90% of Individuals who die of COVID-19 have diabetes or different well being circumstances. Here is what may very well be placing you at a better danger for the virus. USA TODAY

The declare: Specialists exaggerate the gravity of COVID-19 dying charges as compared with the Spanish flu and seasonal flu

Many claims have tried to check the COVID-19 pandemic with prior pandemics, such because the Spanish flu in 1918 or the swine flu in 2009. Others have tried to brush off the novel coronavirus signs and fee of an infection as akin to the seasonal flu.

USA TODAY debunked the declare that there have been 56 million fewer instances of COVID-19 than of the H1N1 virus, or swine flu, through the first 12 months of that pandemic.

Two different claims suggesting a second Spanish flu pandemic wave had a better dying fee than the primary had been additionally discovered to be inaccurate.

A extensively shared meme incorporates a barely altered model of the declare. One Fb put up of the meme from late July has been shared greater than 50,000 instances. USA TODAY reached out to the poster for remark, and he replied with extra statistics that would not be independently verified.

Reality test: Governors, president each liable for pandemic response

Digging into the numbers

Within the meme, well being consultants are accused of overreacting about COVID-19 as compared with the H1N1 pandemic of 1918 (the Spanish flu) and the seasonal flu. The meme begins with the road “How massive is 1%?” It then provides statistics for every pandemic and the seasonal flu, together with world inhabitants, variety of contaminated folks and fatality fee in contrast with the world inhabitants.

The meme says 50 million folks, 5.26% of an estimated international inhabitants of 950 million, died of the Spanish flu, then says, “Specialists: TRAGIC EVENT!”

Although it’s true that about 50 million folks died from the Spanish flu, in keeping with an estimate from the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention, the International Change Knowledge Lab locations the estimated world inhabitants in 1918 at 1.8 billion. An article in 2006 within the well being journal Rising Infectious Illnesses, printed by the CDC, cites a 2.5% international mortality fee. The pandemic lasted for 2 years, from spring 1918 into spring 1920.

Is COVID-19 worse than the 1918 Spanish flu? Examine reveals deaths in New York quadrupled in early months

In 2018, 650,000 of an estimated 7.5 billion folks, or 0.009%,  died of the seasonal flu worldwide. Specialists known as this a “typical 12 months,” in keeping with the meme.

This a part of the meme is correct. Yearly, 3 million to five million folks globally contract the seasonal flu, leading to about 290,000 to 650,000 deaths, in keeping with the World Well being Group. The WHO estimates the annual worldwide mortality fee is lower than 0.1%, impartial U.Okay. fact-checker Full Reality reported.

The meme says a minimum of 488,729 of an estimated 7.7 billion folks have died of COVID-19. There isn’t any date related to the meme, however the worldwide dying depend reached greater than a half-million June 28, USA TODAY reported.

“1% of the World’s Pop proper now can be 77 million useless. Now if 5.26% is TRAGIC and .009 is NO BIG DEAL, what the HELL are we doing!” the meme ends. 

International deaths from COVID-19 handed 776,000 in mid-August, in keeping with the Johns Hopkins College Coronavirus Useful resource Middle.

Reality test: Hydroxychloroquine doesn’t work higher overseas

Is COVID-19 extra lethal than Spanish flu or seasonal flu?

A report printed Aug. 13 within the medical journal JAMA Community Open in contrast the 2 months after the primary recorded dying from COVID-19 in New York Metropolis with the deadliest two months of the Spanish flu pandemic.

Researchers discovered that though there have been extra deaths per 100,000 folks through the peak of the Spanish flu, the toll was nonetheless akin to deaths through the COVID-19 outbreak.

The distinction lies in baseline mortality charges. Folks died of causes not related to H1N1 in 1918, due to poorer hygiene, public well being and security. Due to this fact, researchers discovered the relative enhance through the early interval of the COVID-19 epidemic was “considerably better” than the height of the Spanish flu pandemic.

“This time round – with extra superior medical care and public well being methods bringing fatalities right down to 50 a month per 100,000 throughout the identical March-to-Might dates the earlier three years – the variety of deaths quadrupled,” USA TODAY reported Aug. 13. 

Specialists decided COVID-19 to be extra lethal than the seasonal flu. There’s a vaccine for the seasonal flu, conserving instances down; there’s not a vaccine for COVID-19.

The COVID-19  ratio of deaths per 100 instances within the USA was 3.1% as of Thursday, and the approximate 0.05% mortality fee is likely one of the highest on the earth, in keeping with Johns Hopkins College. Solely Peru, Spain, Chile and Brazil are greater.  

The CDC reported that the annual mortality fee for the seasonal flu is about 0.01%, or 12,000-61,000 deaths per 12 months.

In response to the newest knowledge accessible  from the CDC, COVID-19 has an general an infection mortality ratio of 0.0065. That ratio is outlined because the proportion of dying amongst all contaminated people. The proportion of transmission from asymptomatic carriers is 50%. The worldwide case fatality fee – the ratio between confirmed deaths and confirmed instances – reached 3.5% Thursday, in accordance to the International Change Knowledge Lab.

For additional comparability, 151,700-575,400 folks worldwide died from H1N1 an infection through the pandemic in 2009, in keeping with the CDC. Individuals accounted for 12,469. Greater than 174,000 have died from COVID-19 within the USA, in keeping with the Coronavirus Useful resource Middle. A vaccine for the swine flu turned accessible about 5 months after the primary confirmed U.S. case, USA TODAY reported. 

Nonetheless, the International Change Knowledge Lab said an intensive COVID-19 mortality evaluation ought to embody the probability of dying for an contaminated individual, or the an infection fatality fee. The whole variety of instances and deaths are wanted to precisely calculate this fee. A lot of elements, together with undertesting, make it tough for researchers to find out the overall case quantity.

USA TODAY discovered the comparability offered within the meme merely with numbers is just not a good one. The novel coronavirus spreads extra rapidly and is extra contagious than the seasonal flu. 

Reality test: 2009 swine flu unfold quickly, however COVID-19 is extra lethal

Our ranking: Partly false

We fee this declare as PARTLY FALSE, based mostly on our analysis. The preliminary declare offered largely correct statistics for the flu epidemic in 1918 and seasonal flu mortality charges. However COVID-19 has been deadlier than both of those ailments, in keeping with consultants and research. Although the variety of folks useless from COVID-19 as a share of world inhabitants at one time limit could also be an correct quantity, it isn’t reflective of the mortality fee of the virus. The mortality fee  is roughly 0.05% within the USA alone. That is among the many highest on the earth and better than the annual seasonal flu mortality fee, in keeping with the newest knowledge.

Our fact-check sources:

  • Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention: “2009 H1N1 Pandemic (H1N1pdm09 virus)”
  • Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention: “Illness Burden of Influenza”
  • World Well being Group, Nov. 6, 2018: “Ask the professional: Influenza Q&A”
  • Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention: “1918 Pandemic (H1N1 virus)”
  • USA TODAY, Aug. 13, 2020: “Is COVID-19 worse than the 1918 Spanish flu? Examine reveals deaths in New York quadrupled in early months”
  • Johns Hopkins College, accessed Aug. 20, 2020: “Mortality Analyses” 
  • Johns Hopkins College, accessed Aug. 20, 2020: “Coronavirus Useful resource Middle Map”
  • Our World in Knowledge, March 4, 2020: “The Spanish flu (1918-20): The worldwide impression of the biggest influenza pandemic in historical past”
  • USA TODAY, June 30, 2020: “Reality test: There isn’t any common pandemic trajectory; COVID-19 could not have worse 2nd wave”
  • USA TODAY, April 25, 2020: “Reality test: Was second wave of Spanish flu worse? Did it kill a minimum of 20 million folks?”
  • Rising Infectious Illnesses, Jan. 12, 2006: “1918 Influenza: the Mom of All Pandemics”
  • Full Reality, March 11, 2020: “How does the brand new coronavirus evaluate to influenza?”
  • International Change Knowledge Lab, //accessed Aug. 20, 2020: “Coronavirus Pandemic Knowledge Explorer”
  • Our World in Knowledge, accessed Aug. 21, 2020: “Mortality Danger of COVID-19”

Thanks for supporting our journalism. You may subscribe to our print version, ad-free app or digital newspaper reproduction right here.

Our reality test work is supported partially by a grant from Fb.


Present Thumbnails

Present Captions

Final SlideNext Slide

Learn or Share this story:


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *